The November 19 release of Grand Theft Auto VI, 13 years after its predecessor, has many New York Jets fans entering a time machine and figuring out what else has changed in the decade plus between releases.
In the time between the two entries, which resulted in a whopping zero playoff games for Gang Green, the Jets continued their infamous run of NFL Draft whiffs that played a big part in the team's consistent losing ways.
These 10 players all stand out as the biggest busts in the Jets' playoff-less streak. Will Rockstar's new release be what kicks the Jets' cosmic imbalance back in line?
10 biggest New York Jets draft busts of the Grand Theft Auto V era
10. DE Jachai Polite, Florida (No. 69 overall, 2019)
Putting a third-round pick on this list might be controversial, but when Malachi Corley is a provably better Jet than you, it's hard to keep him out of the Top 10. Polite was once viewed as a first-round talent the Jets stole in the third round, and he was selected to be a key part of the team's pass rush. He didn't even make it out of the preseason before being cut.
Polite, who reportedly piled up over six figures in fines for tardiness and other transgressions, had one sack as a COVID-era depth signing for the Rams, and then he was gone. Polite's dismissal from the NFL was almost entirely self-inflicted.
Passed On: Maxx Crosby, Terry McLaurin, David Montgomery
9. DE Will McDonald, Iowa State (No. 15 overall, 2023)
McDonald is not a bad player, as he tallied 18.5 sacks in a two-season span. However, the Jets expected his speed off the edge to become one of the defining aspects of their defense, and he never managed that. This pick looks even worse when looking at some of the players picked after someone rarely regarded as a first-round pick.
Christian Gonzalez has given the rival New England Patriots a rock-solid No. 1 cornerback for the future, while Jaxon Smith-Njigba is perhaps the best receiver in football. The Jets would love either one of those instead of a No. 3 pass rusher.
Passed On: Jaxon Smith-NJigba, Christian Gonzalez, Puka Nacua
8. WR Devin Smith, Ohio State (No. 37 overall, 2015)
Everything about Smith screamed future star. He came from a loaded program, showed tremendous deep speed, and had exceptional ball skills. In the pros, however, Smith was never able to stay healthy, as tearing the same ACL twice in three seasons was a death sentence.
By 2017, after recording just 10 catches and one touchdown, Smith was done in New York. After a few catches with Dallas and Jacksonville in seasons after that, Smith left the NFL. If only he were healthy.
Passed On: Danielle Hunter, Stefon Diggs, Tyler Lockett
7. S Calvin Pryor, Louisville (No. 18 overall, 2014)
Maybe the Jets need to stay away from Louisville players. Pryor was drafted due to his hard-hitting style of play, but his coverage skills were a work in progress. Rather than seeing that as a massive red flag, the Jets tried to work with him, and they failed miserably.
Pryor was tossed aside after only three seasons, two interceptions, and innumerable blown coverages. Pryor was traded to the Cleveland Browns for Demario Davis (oddly enough) and played just two games for the Jaguars before the NFL was done with him in 2017. Pryor wasn't even viewed as quality depth in the NFL.
Passed On: Davante Adams, Derek Carr, Demarcus Lawrence
6. OT Mekhi Becton, Louisville (No. 11 overall, 2020)
The only time in Becton's career in which he showed any promise was his rookie season, as injuries cost him almost all of the next two seasons. 2023 was a nightmare, as the lethal cocktail of feuding with coaches, horrible pass protection, and penalty problems sunk him in New York.
Becton's breakout season as a guard with the Philadelphia Eagles was followed by a disgusting Los Angeles Chargers stint and some horrid snaps for the Green Bay Packers in 2026. Becton's size was impressive, but his health and lack of great technique were too much to overcome.
Passed On: Tristan Wirfs, CeeDee Lamb, Justin Jefferson
5. QB Christian Hackenberg, Penn State (No. 51 overall, 2016
Drafting a quarterback many believed was a late Day 3 dart throw in the middle of the second round was questionable enough, as was rolling into the season with four quarterbacks on the roster. Picking someone so bad that he never got on the field in an NFL game is legendary stuff.
Hackenberg, released after two seasons, zero regular-season snaps, and some of the worst passing lines you've ever seen in the preseason, proved the haters right in the AAF. After being benched by the Memphis Express, Hackenberg was done. Turns out being tall with a strong arm doesn't guarantee success.
Passed On: Dak Prescott, Kevin Byard, Joe Thuney
4. QB Sam Darnold, USC (No. 3 overall, 2018)
While Darnold was able to show that he is a solid NFL quarterback by winning a championship with the Seattle Seahawks, his Jets career was a huge flop. Yes, they threw Darnold to the wolves with an Adam Gase-led staff and no skill-position talent, but he didn't help elevate this team.
Darnold went 13-25 as a starter, throwing 45 touchdowns against 39 interceptions and going 2-10 during his third season in the pros. After struggling in Carolina following a trade, Darnold's unlikely career resurgence doesn't negate his New York struggles.
Passed On: Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, Fred Warner
3. LB Darron Lee, Ohio State (No. 20 overall, 2016)
Lee has been indicted on a charge of first-degree murder for the death of 29-year-old Gabriela Perpetuo, which could carry a term of life in prison if convicted. Before those ghoulish allegations came to light, Lee was one of the worst linebackers in the league for almost the entirety of his Jets career.
Lee was a great athlete with terrible football sense, as he was routinely bowled over by running backs and toasted in coverage. Lee was a seldom-used backup for a few years before fading out of the league, and now he is in the middle of a frightening legal situation.
Passed On: Dak Prescott, Kevin Byard, Joe Thuney (twice)
2. CB Dee Milliner, Alabama (No. 9 overall, 2013)
Every Alabama defensive back picked this high in the draft seems to make an impact, except for Milliner. Barring one extreme outlier stretch in the final month of his rookie season, Milliner's play was so bad that Rex Ryan and the coaching staff would routinely throw him on the bench after giving up big chunk plays.
Milliner was getting hurt routinely, and those injuries certainly didn't help, but he was simply not a competent NFL starter. No wonder the 2013 first-rounder never played after 2014 and was never even on a roster past 2016.
Passed On: DeAndre Hopkins, Travis Kelce, Tyrann Mathieu
1. QB Zach Wilson, BYU (No. 2 overall, 2021)
Let's just look at what happened on the field. Wilson threw more interceptions than touchdowns in parts of three seasons as the starter, which included a Year 2 benching and an Aaron Rodgers trade mixed in. He never improved his issues while under pressure, evaded accountability, and somehow regressed later in his career. The crater he left in his wake may somehow be even more destructive.
Wilson has found work with the Broncos, Dolphins, and Saints, but has rarely seen anything more than inactive QB3 work. Wilson is not just an all-time Jets bust; he's an all-time NFL bust.
Passed On: Micah Parsons, Penei Sewell, Ja'Marr Chase
