Skip to main content

Jets clearly have their Breece Hall-Braelon Allen roles all wrong after Bills loss

This needs to be reversed.
ByCharlie Baduini
New York Jets running back Braelon Allen
New York Jets running back Braelon Allen | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

We've now seen two games' worth of the New York Jets' backfield with Breece Hall back in the mix alongside Braelon Allen, and it's safe to say whatever magic the Jets' running game once had with Allen as the bell-cow back is long gone.

Now, in fairness, New York's last two games haven't exactly been run-game friendly. Week 9's matchup with the Kansas City Chiefs got out of hand in the second half fairly quickly, and Week 10 against the Buffalo Bills was hardly different. But still, the Jets had Allen going over 100 scrimmage yards on a routine basis throughout the month of October.

Since Hall has been back in the fold, he has been given his old role as the Jets' starting running back. He's carried the ball 26 times for 102 rushing yards, good for 3.9 yards per carry. Remember, Allen was averaging 5.4 yards per carry when he was the bell-cow guy.

One game was one thing, but now with two full outings under their belts, it's clear that the Jets have the roles all wrong between Allen and Hall. The 22-year-old should be the every-down runner, while Hall and his shiftiness are best served as the third-down back.

New York Jets need to reverse roles for their running backs

Even with a decreased role over the last two weeks, Allen has still been the more efficient running back than Hall. He's been given 16 carries and has turned them into 73 yards, good for 4.5 yards per rush. That efficiency shouldn't be ignored.

This isn't a knock on Hall. He's still a valuable player and can be a contributing piece for a winning offense, but at this point in his career, is he really best suited as a bell-cow guy?

That answer is likely no, and the Jets would be best served to keep running with Allen as their primary running back. But there are two major problems with that scenario.

One: Hall would likely not take that demotion well. Before his return in Week 9, he made a point when talking to the media to say that he's "still a starter," which seemed like a clear sign that he wasn't going to be taking a backseat once he was back in the lineup.

Two: his price tag. The Jets just inked Hall to a lucrative three-year, $43.5 million deal. How do you relegate a guy making $14.5 million per year to a part-time role?

You don't, and that's part of the problem. It's why a trade seemed like such a good idea ahead of the deadline, but the Jets were obviously set in their stance not to sell off any major pieces.

This will be a fascinating saga to watch unfold as the rest of the 2026 season trudges on, and of course, into 2027 when a new coach likely takes over and decides how he wants to deploy the Jets' two-headed backfield.

Add us as a preferred source on Google