The New York Jets were forced to turn to fourth-round rookie Cade Klubnik at quarterback during their Week 10 loss against the Buffalo Bills, as Geno Smith was evaluated for a concussion and later left the game with what is being deemed an ankle injury. As was to be expected, Klubnik had a mixed debut.
The Jets may be forced to lean on Klubnik in Week 11 against the winless Los Angeles Chargers, which have many fans watching with bated breath as they try to solidify a high pick in the 2027 NFL Draft.
If Smith is still recovering from his ankle injury, starting Klubnik in the name of "seeing what he's got" might not be the worst idea in the world. However, when fully healthy, this is still Smith's job, and Klubnik would need quite the performance to snatch that job away from Geno.
Jets should start Cade Klubnik in Week 11 while Geno Smith gets healthy
Klubnik finished the Buffalo game 11-20 passing for 137 yards, no touchdowns, and one interception. The pick came on a hideous overthrow, but he also managed to keep drives alive with his legs and hit Garrett Wilson downfield on a few big plays. Considering the opponent and situation, Klubnik should be commended for a few bright spots.
The Chargers, who enter their Monday Night duel with the Baltimore Ravens winless at 0-8, are a much worse opponent than Buffalo. Still, the defense has been able to kick things into high gear at times, and they could provide Klubnik with enough resistance to stress the uneven rookie.
Unless the Jets do a Brady Cook and openly waive the white flag on another season around Thanksgiving, and unless Klubnik somehow manages to turn into prime Aaron Rodgers in his first start, Smith should still be in line for starting action once his ankle is fully healed up.
The Jets should start Geno Smith over Cade Klubnik when he is healthy
The Jets will likely roll with Smith when everyone is healthy, as they should. He may not be good enough to pile up wins and further put a top pick out of reach, but he is competent enough to make sure that the young prospects like Kenyon Sadiq, Mason Taylor, and Omar Cooper Jr. are being fed while Wilson is kept happy.
If Smith wants to play in 2027, there could be no better scenario for whomever the Jets draft than sitting behind Geno before getting thrown into the line of fire. Benching the impending free agent might make it more difficult to retain him, as he may have options elsewhere. Taking care of Geno for 2027 should be a priority, lest another rookie be thrown into a meat grinder.
Starting Klubnik wouldn't be a Cook-level tank move, but it would be refusing to put their top picks in a developmental environment that would get the most out of them. Geno showing that he could be a bridge starter in 2027 might be one positive thing to come out of this crushingly disappointing season.
