Skip to main content

In no world should the Jets consider trading for lame duck HC Shane Steichen

Anytime you can trade for a coach about to be fired, you just have to do it.
ByMatt O'Leary
Indianapolis Colts head coach Shane Steichen
Indianapolis Colts head coach Shane Steichen | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

It's idea season. When a football team is 2-8, on a fast track to a top pick in the draft, and their coach is just counting down the minutes until they're fired, the ideas start to come out. These usually tend to be hit or miss.

As a content creator, I'm all about idea season. It's a fun time to play pretend and try to fix the New York Jets. However, when people who aren't as plugged into the day-to-day operation start chiming in, sometimes it gets a little wacky.

That's what happened this week when The Athletic Football Show suggested the Jets trade a first-round pick for Indianapolis Colts head coach Shane Steichen.

Jets urged to trade for Shane Steichen for no good reason

This is nothing against The Athletic Football Show, which is usually a fine program; I just really don't understand the logic of trying to trade a first-round pick for a coach who is going to get fired in seven weeks.

In the last 20 games he's coached, the Colts are just 4-16. They started the season 7-1 in 2025 and went just 1-8 over their final nine games, and then he's followed that up with a 3-8 start to the 2026 season.

The Colts were major sellers at the trade deadline; they just released Daniel Jones; they are going into tank mode, and Steichen will be on the hook for all of these losses that are about to come. The Colts are hitting the reset button at the end of the year; the Jets wouldn't have to trade for him regardless.

In his four seasons with the Colts, Steichen has just a 45.2 win percentage. His offenses were in the top half of the league in points in just two of the four years he's been there, and this year they rank 26th.

Even if we want to pass the blame onto the former general manager and the owner, I don't see Steichen as a good fit as a head coach. If someone wants to bring Steichen along as the offensive coordinator next season, I can get behind that.

However, after a four-year run, he likely needs to take a year or two away from the head coaching position, learn from his mistakes, regain his position as a good offensive play caller, and then get back into the head coaching cycle a few years from now.

The Kevin O'Connell trade discussion from this week was a little bit more realistic than this discussion. At least KOC has a 64.9 win percentage in his career, has his team in a playoff spot, and will likely finish with a winning record in four of his five seasons as a head coach.

The O'Connell pipe dream is just that, though: a dream. If the Jets gave up a draft pick for Steichen, that would be a nightmare.

Add us as a preferred source on Google