The New York Jets defense may have looked marginally different the last two weeks against both the Kansas City Chiefs and Buffalo Bills. With Andre Cisco on the trade block and, of course, eventually shipped to Detroit before the deadline, second-year safety Malachi Moore saw an increased workload.
He hasn't been a starter or anything, but he saw a 17-snap workload in Kansas City and a whopping 28-snap day against Buffalo. While it's nice to see the Jets starting to turn to their young players as the 2026 season begins to wind down, this is one New York may be better off pulling the plug on.
Moore had a really bad day against the Bills; despite playing 49% of the snaps, his most of the season, he graded out as the Jets' worst player according to Pro Football Focus. He earned a grade of 28.6 and was the main culprit on D.J. Moore's 45-yard touchdown grab from Josh Allen.
The 2025 fourth-round draft pick played in every game last season and had every opportunity to win the starting job opposite Minkah Fitzpatrick this past summer. But all he's shown over his short NFL career is that he's not cut out to be a main contributor on defense, and the Jets should know that by now.
New York Jets can't keep playing Malachi Moore
The problem isn't that the Jets are down to their last option in their secondary at this point. Behind Moore, they have first-year defensive backs D'Angelo Ponds and VJ Payne waiting in the wings.
Ponds is traditionally a cornerback and has mostly played nickel in smaller spurts throughout his young NFL career. But if the Jets are going to play Moore as a third safety or in the slot, why can't Ponds do the same?
On top of that, the Jets are better off giving their seventh-round rookie a chance on the back end. Payne, who only just made his return this month after missing the first half of the season with a knee injury, could offer something different than either Ponds or Moore.
With a 4.40 40-yard dash and a 6-foot-3, 206-pound build, Payne brings a certain level of athleticism that the Jets don't currently have on their defense.
Regardless, it doesn't matter who the Jets decide to give more playing time to. All that is clear at this point is that Moore shouldn't be playing an expanded role on defense. He just can't handle it right now.
