Skip to main content

✈️ Jets Air Traffic Report Week 10: Klubnik raises questions about Jets' offense as losses continue to stack

Cade Klubnik may have exposed something about this New York Jets' offense in one half of football. But what he revealed doesn't fix the problem.
ByMichael Carmella
Nov 15, 2026; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA;  New York Jets quarterback Cade Klubnik (10) throws the ball during the second half against the Buffalo Bills at MetLife Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
Nov 15, 2026; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; New York Jets quarterback Cade Klubnik (10) throws the ball during the second half against the Buffalo Bills at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Cade Klubnik just made it clear what's been going on with this New York Jets' offense in 2026.

Throughout this series, we've tried to assess this Jets' passing attack, the play of Geno Smith, the playcalling of Frank Reich, and the tale that's being told.

Thankfully, against the Buffalo Bills, Klubnik helped to tie up a few storylines.

This offense works, and this offense sucks, but neither one supports the Geno Smith glorification

Why Smith has been made to seem like the victim of Reich's bad playcalling this season, I have no idea.

Maybe it was his surprising interception-free streak to start the year, or perhaps the public sees his numbers and assumes greatness, but this game gave us insight into the exact role Smith has been playing.

After an injury to Smith, rookie Klubnik took over one drive into the second half. The result: a nearly identical stat line to Smith's first-half totals.

Oversimplification-- sure. But with the way the world has praised Smith this year, I'd say that a rookie making his NFL debut on no notice being able to put up even remotely close numbers is pretty damning evidence that the praise is undeserved.

To me, it actually vindicated Reich as a playcaller, if anything. I mean, what better way to assess an offense's effectiveness than to completely swap its primary cog in the middle of the game?

I'll dive deeper into what this game showed us about Reich below, but let's start with the kid.

Cade Klubnik showed some surprisingly impressive signs

As someone who played the position, when I watch a young quarterback, I look for a few things.

First, I want to see them give up the ball. No, I don't mean turnovers. I mean that when passes are called, they actually throw them.

Unless you've been in the situation, you can't truly imagine the fear coursing through your bones. You're scared to get hit; you're scared to look stupid, but most importantly, you're scared to screw up.

In that moment, the football feels like it's your own heart that is somehow outside of your chest cavity and in your trembling hands. To string together the series of thoughts and actions that result in you letting it leave your death grip is nothing short of remarkable.

In this sense, Klubnik was impressive. His very first throw was a deep touch pass to Garrett Wilson. If there's anything more terrifying than what I just described, it's doing it with a throw that leaves your football/heart hanging in the air, up for grabs to all. I thought the kid showed some cojones with this.

The second thing I look for is, what awaits them when those passes are thrown.

Doesn't matter if the throw is accurate. Doesn't matter if it's caught. Is there one defender or three around that particular receiver?

It tells me that you're making the right reads, even if you're not making good throws. Klubnik did this exceptionally well.

He completed several throws against zone coverage to targets in big windows, gave receivers a chance against single-man coverage, and only once did he throw to a blanketed option, and he actually completed it with a bullet driven to Mason Taylor.

Even the interception was the correct read. Just a god-awful throw.

Lastly, I look at shoulders.

Young quarterbacks, especially nervous ones, tend to do the same thing, which is to point their front shoulder way up to the sky. Part of that is being generally tense, the same way your shoulders flex up in any stressful situation. The other reason, however, is that it means your weight is on your back foot.

As a quarterback, you generally want a strong base. Even weight distribution between your back and front foot makes any sudden movement or throw more achievable. When you introduce nerves, that weight starts to shift back as your mind screams, "retreat". The result? Sky shoulder.

At this, Klubnik was just okay.

This game finds Frank Reich not guilty as a playcaller, but only of one count

The fact that Klubnik found several open receivers means there were open receivers.

If he had thrown exclusively screens, shallow drags, and flat routes, I wouldn't be making this claim. As it was, the rookie was pushing the ball into the impressive depth range and completing passes on a variety of concepts.

If nothing else, Klubnik showed us from the broadcast angle what those downfield matchups have potentially looked like all year. Something Smith has left up to our imagination by only ever throwing within the scope of the television wide shot.

In my assessment, I saw a lot of pretty good options.

That being said, the failed hook-and-ladder attempt, while honorable, was so embarrassing I almost wish they hadn't tried. The redzone playcalling was once again abysmal. And it's clear that while I will continue to defend Reich from the wolves in certain areas, this offense lacks any kind of sequencing or consideration of the defense it is facing.

Reich is still guilty, but not of the crimes he's being charged with, and Smith is not the savior he's been made out to be.

Overall Rating: 7.9 👍

Like a setup episode of your favorite thriller series. Not the most exciting, but important because of what you learned. You assumed you were dumb and accepted not understanding certain storylines, but now that you do, next week is definitely more interesting.

Add us as a preferred source on Google