We canāt say that we were exactly surprised to see CBS Sportsā Pete Prisco mock Ohio State linebacker Arvell Reese to the New York Jets, especially given recent trends.
Priscoās reasoning, though, was certainly different than the typical āheās the best non-quarterback,ā or the āJets need impactful playmakersā take weāve become used to reading.
āOk, so maybe his pro day workout wasnāt great,ā Prisco wrote in his April 6 mock draft. āBut his tape is impressive. You donāt draft off pro days.ā
Prisco is technically correct, which some might argue is the best kind of correct.
Pete Prisco is correct: NFL teams should never draft off the Combine or Pro Days
As someone who enjoys watching the NFL Draft each year, Iāve become immensely frustrated by the lack of context we often use when grading drafts retrospectively.
The Bengals selecting Washington Huskies receiver John Ross No. 9 in 2017 wasnāt an awful pick solely because Patrick Mahomes went to the Chiefs one spot later. Instead, the pick should be looked at with a massive, crimson-colored āFā because Rossā 4.22 40-yard dash at the combine shot him up draft boards.
In other words, the Bengals seemingly allowed a workout to force them into drafting a one-year starting receiver with an injury history. Suffice to say, it didnāt work out well.
Thatās not to say that the NFL Combine, Pro Days, and top-30 visits donāt matter. Teams want to hear what a player thinks or see how they break down plays. Thatās why the Raiders' drafting JaMarcus Russell in 2007, despite his infamously lying about watching a blank DVD, was so egregious.
In theory, a teamās decision to draft or sign a player should come down to various factors blended into one final evaluation. What does his tape look like? How did players and coaches perceive him? What did opposing coaches do to game-plan against him? When you met with him, what was the vibe you got?
We know what Reese can do, and weāve heard the All-American linebackerās statistics for weeks. How many more times can we hear about his ceiling before going into draft night believing heās going to turn the Jets into a perennial contender?
So, if and when Reese goes to the Jets at No. 2, itāll ideally be because the Jets feel that his tape justified him going that high. The last thing that Aaron Glenn and the Jets need is their own John Ross situation.
