2013 New York Jets NFL Draft Grade Roundup

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse

Apr 26, 2013; Florham Park, NJ, USA; New York Jets first round selection cornerback Dee Milliner answers questions during a press conference at the New York Jets Training Facility. Mandatory Credit: Jim O

Vinnie Iyer, Sporting News

Grade: D

New York Jets: Their entire draft will ride on just how good West Virginia’s Geno Smith will be as their starting quarterback, and there’s reason to believe the pairing will be quite bumpy. In essence, they swapped out Darrelle Revis for Alabama’s Dee Milliner at cornerback, but wasted the No. 13 they got for Revis by taking Sheldon Richardson, a tackle better suited for the 4-3, not Rex Ryan’s 3-4. It was a shaky start for John Idzik.

Harsh stuff from Iyer. Again, here is a guy assuming that the Jets are going to remain in the 3-4 base. Why can’t they be moving to more of a 4-3 feature set? Like we talked about yesterday, it’s possible, isn’t it?

Pete Prisco, CBS Sports

New York Jets

Best pick: He doesn’t look like a fit in their current defense, but Sheldon Richardson, their second first-round pick, is a heck of a player.

Questionable move: Taking Dee Milliner in the first round. Milliner has a lot of injury concerns and they had other needs.

Third-day gem: Fifth-round guard Oday Aboushi is a college tackle who will have to move inside on the next level.

Analysis: They took solid players with their two first-round picks and then came back to take Geno Smith in the second round. Smith will push for a job as the starting quarterback, so he will be the key to grading this down the road.

Grade: C

C is still a rough grade in my opinion, but his concerns about the players chosen are a bit more legitimate than some of the other concerns I have read so far.

And finally, Fox Sports

Floyd Engel: (B) Anybody who thinks the Jets’ objective should have been getting help for Mark Sanchez did not watch Mark Sanchez last year. They needed a QB, and Geno Smith in the second round is solid. If he fails, get another next year.

Marvez: (C+) The talk of this draft wasn’t the two first-round picks (Alabama cornerback Dee Milliner and Missouri defensive tackle Sheldon Richardson) but Smith, who took an unexpected tumble deep into the second round. Even with their awful quarterbacking situation, the Jets must mitigate pressure to prematurely play Smith because he may need a year of seasoning while adjusting to a West Coast-style offense after playing in a spread system at West Virginia.

Schrager: (C+) They wanted Tavon Austin and didn’t get him. Smith, to me, is not a good fit for this team and situation, either. The Jets had a circus already and I’m not convinced Geno can start in Year One. Other than Geno Smith, the Jets did add guys who can help the defense on Day 1 in Milliner and Richardson and an offensive lineman I really like in Brian Winters out of Kent State.

It’s interesting to note how there isn’t a clear view on this draft. The grades range from B-D, rather than being close together. How do you guys feel about what these experts have to say?

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse
Next Jets Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00Oakland RaidersBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: 2013 Nfl Draft New York Jets

  • matr dontelli iii

    they all showed why they work for peanuts instead of riches. absolutely no insight, nothing new, let’s just bash the jets every chance we get. don’t any of them think that maybe idzik and ryan spoke before the draft to see if they could use richardson on the defense or if he would just be a useless waste of a roster spot on the bench? nobody realizes that the injury prone cornerback we just traded was replaced by the more athletic and versatile cromartie? i mean they’re real good at putting the other guy in the hall of fame but let’s be fair. does he return kicks? does he line up on offense and draw a double team? has he been on the field more than cro the last three years? is he really worth twice what they pay cro? not even close. i didn’t wanna see them draft smith, but they got him in the second when he was widely regarded as the draft’s best qb. if they didn’t grab him they’d all be roasting us for not drafting him when he was available in the second, ‘despite having the embattled mark sanchez and the injury prone gerrard, who hasn’t played in the last two years as the only viable options, the jets failed to address the qb spot when top-rated qb geno smith was available in the second round. grade d.’ the new oc and running backs will improve the offense. the new o line will improve the offense. if the qb doesn’t turn the ball over like he’s got money riding on the other team the offense will improve. there were just too may holes to fill with 8 picks and austin was gone before we picked. we coulda tried a mr t. move and switched picks with buffalo. that woulda cost us a king’s ransom and guaranteed that austin was a bust (using jet trade-up luck as a basis). and we woulda got roasted for that too. you know who was fairest toward us for the draft? of all people? dick cimini, believe it or not!

    • TheJetPress

      Being a long time fan like you are, you know as well as anybody that we are damned if we do, damned if we don’t. I believe we could theoretically draft Dan Marino, Jerry Rice, and Jim Brown in succession, and the draft experts would still find problems. Ah, the life of a Jets fan.

      • matr dontelli iii

        There is only one cure, and I think we’ve got the right people leading and I think we’re on the right track. Time will tell, until then the most ignorant will have the loudest voices.

        • TheJetPress

          My voice is getting louder, so is Joe’s over at TOJ…….the smart are slowly taking over for the ignorant lol

  • Pingback: New York Jets 2013 NFL Draft Class Could Have Huge Immediate Impact - The Jet Press - A New York Jets Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and more.